Sunday, February 12, 2006

The mind's 'Enigma machine' #2

The mind's 'Enigma machine', Daily Telegraph, 24 January 2006, Roger Highfield ...

[Continued from part #1. My comments are bold and in square brackets.]

One third of the MASC machine is present in the yeast, a simple organism which lacks a nervous system, revealing how the human brain is probably the descendant of machinery to help our ancestors adapt to their surroundings. [I have no problem with this, since I accept common ancestry. But Darwinists typically think that if they can identify part of the machinery (in this case only "One third"), in a possible ancestor, then that of itself demonstrates it "evolved" by a `blind watchmaker' process. That is because in their heads they think of the only alternative to "evolution" as instantaneous, ex nihilo creation, as Darwin evidently did, thinking that the only alternative to evolution was "miraculous act[s] of creation" where "certain elemental atoms have been commanded suddenly to flash into living tissues":

"Several eminent naturalists have of late published their belief that a multitude of reputed species in each genus are not real species; but that other species are real, that is, have been independently created. This seems to me a strange conclusion to arrive at. They admit that a multitude of forms, which till lately they themselves thought were special creations, and which are still thus looked at by the majority of naturalists, and which consequently have all the external characteristic features of true species,- they admit that these have been produced by variation, but they refuse to extend the same view to other and slightly different forms. Nevertheless they do not pretend that they can define, or even conjecture, which are the created forms of life, and which are those produced by secondary laws. They admit variation as a vera causa in one case, they arbitrarily reject it in another, without assigning any distinction in the two cases. The day will come when this will be given as a curious illustration of the blindness of preconceived opinion. These authors seem no more startled at a miraculous act of creation than at an ordinary birth. But do they really believe that at innumerable periods in the earth's history certain elemental atoms have been commanded suddenly to flash into living tissues? Do they believe that at each supposed act of creation one individual or many were produced? Were all the infinitely numerous kinds of animals and plants created as eggs or seed, or as full grown? and in the case of mammals, were they created bearing the false marks of nourishment from the mother's womb? Undoubtedly some of these same questions cannot be answered by those who believe in the appearance or creation of only a few forms of life, or of some one form alone. It has been maintained by several authors that it is as easy to believe in the creation of a million beings as of one; but Maupertuis's philosophical axiom `of least action' leads the mind more willingly to admit the smaller number, and certainly we ought not to believe that innumerable beings within each great class have been created with plain, but deceptive, marks of descent from a single parent.' (Darwin C.R., `The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection,' [1872], Everyman's Library, J.M. Dent & Sons: London, 6th Edition, 1928, reprint, pp.456-457)

But that is a delusion because a far-sighted Intelligent Designer can create parts for a simple machines with a long-term plan to use that simpler machine as part of a later, more complex machine. What Darwinists need to do is show how (and why) a `blind watchmaker' could (and would ) do it. I have added Darwin's quote above to my "Problems of Evolution" book outline, PE 2. 8.7 "Fallacies used to support evolution ... False alternative (False Dilemma)"]

The researchers have shown that dozens of the proteins in the MASC are essential for learning, for memory and are implicated in human diseases of the nervous system, making it a major new focus for research. When one of the proteins that make up MASC is lacking or is mutated in a disease, then the overall function is impaired and there is a permanent change in the nerve cell and the way it works. [This sounds like a form of irreducible complexity (see below).]

The proteins in MASC made many connections and these can be represented as a wiring diagram. [A "wiring diagram"!]

Dr Douglas Armstrong, deputy director of the Edinburgh Centre for Bioinformatics and a senior author, said the methods used to analyse the MASC are similar to those used to study the information flow across the internet or how people interact socially. "For the first time, we have modelled complex activity in nerve cells using these techniques." Like an electrical grid, there are key "hub" components and the network can be severely disrupted if the hub proteins are disturbed. "We found that the genes for different diseases, such as schizophrenia and depression, fall on different clusters, which is a beautiful insight," said Prof Grant. Nearly one third of MASC proteins are involved in human mental illness, such as schizophrenia, bipolar disorder and mental retardation. "When a molecular cog in MASC is broken, the brain handles information abnormally," said Prof Grant. [This may not be strict irreducible complexity, but it still is a problem for a Darwinian `blind watchmaker' to arrive at the completed machine, because it would have to pass through a stage (in fact many stages) where "a molecular cog ... is broken," but which then would be eliminated by natural selection. ]

Drug companies have traditionally targeted molecules that have been known for decades, focusing on the chemical signals that flash between nerve cells. Now that they have the computer that processes these signals, Prof Grant believes the companies will have dozens of new targets for drugs that can change the ability to think, feel and remember. [This repeated reference to "computer" and also "wiring diagram", makes Denton's point that we do not fully appreciate the "ingenuity in biological design" until our technology eventually catches up with it":

"But it is not just the complexity of living systems which is so profoundly challenging, there is also the incredible ingenuity that is so often manifest in their design. Ingenuity in biological design is particularly striking when it is manifest in solutions to problems analogous to those met in our own technology. Without the existence of the camera and the telescope, much of the ingenuity in the design of the eye would not have been perceived. Although the anatomical components of the eye were well known by scientists in the fifteenth century, the ingenuity of its design was not appreciated until the seventeenth century when the basic optics of image formation were first clearly expressed by Kepler and later by Descartes. However, it was only in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, as the construction of optical instruments became more complicated, utilizing a movable iris, a focusing device, and corrections for spherical and chromatic aberration, all features which have their analogue in the eye, that the ingenuity of the optical system could at last be appreciated fully by Darwin and his contemporaries. We now know the eye to be a far more sophisticated instrument than it appeared a hundred years ago. Electro- physiological studies have recently revealed very intricate connections among the nerve cells of the retina, which enable the eye to carry out many types of preliminary data processing of visual information before transmitting it in binary form to the brain. The cleverness of these mechanisms has again been underlined by their close analogy to the sorts of image intensification and clarification processes carried out today by computers, such as those used by NASA, on images transmitted from space. Today it would be more accurate to think of a television camera if we are looking for an analogy to the eye. There are dozens of examples where advances in technology have emphasized the ingenuity of biological design. ... But it is at a molecular level where the analogy between the mechanical and biological worlds is so striking, and the genius of biological design and the perfection of the goals achieved are most pronounced." (Denton M.J., "Evolution: A Theory in Crisis," Burnett: London, 1985, pp.332-333)]

With this new understanding, the MASC "computer" can now be superimposed onto the computer based on networks of nerves to create new models of the human brain, marking what the team believes is one of the biggest advances in understanding the synapse since Sir Charles Sherrington described the brain as "an enchanted loom, where millions of flashing shuttles weave a dissolving pattern - always a meaningful pattern - though never an abiding one." ... [This article makes Denton's point that it is due in part to "advances in ... computer technology that "In the atomic fabric of life we have found a reflection of our own technology. ... as if we had held up a mirror to our own machines" (my emphasis):

"The eerie artefact-like character of life and the analogy with our own advanced machines has an important philosophical consequence, for it provides the means for a powerful reformulation of the old analogical argument to design which has been one of the basic creationist arguments used throughout western history - going back to Aristotle and presented in its classic form by William Paley in his famous watch-to-watchmaker discourse. ... It is only possible to view an unknown object as an artefact if its design exploits well-understood technological principles and its creation can be precisely envisaged. For this reason, stone age man would have had great difficulty in recognizing the products of twentieth-century technology as machines and we ourselves would probably experience the same bewilderment at the artefacts of a technological civilization far in advance of our own. ... It has only been over the past twenty years with the molecular biological revolution and with the advances in cybernetic and computer technology that Hume's criticism has been finally invalidated and the analogy between organisms and machines has at last become convincing. In opening up this extraordinary new world of living technology biochemists have become fellow travellers with science fiction writers, explorers in a world of ultimate technology, wondering incredulously as new miracles of atomic engineering are continually brought to light in the course of their strange adventure into the microcosm of life. In every direction the biochemist gazes, as he journeys through this weird molecular labyrinth sees devices and appliances reminiscent of our own twentieth-century world of advanced technology. In the atomic fabric of life we have found a reflection of our own technology. We have seen a world as artificial as our own and as familiar as if we had held up a mirror to our own machines." (Denton, 1985, pp.339-340)

I have added part of this article to section PE 8.2.5. 6. "Molecular machinery ... MASC brain `computer'" of my "Problems of Evolution" book outline. ]

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"

Saturday, February 11, 2006

The mind's 'Enigma machine' #1

Here is a news item about the discovery that "the human brain is at least 1,000 times more powerful than previously estimated," the result of "200 proteins work[ing] together in a crucial molecular signalling machine" (called "MASC") which is "itself a chemical computer." Isn't the `blind watchmaker' wonderful? :-) My comments are bold and in square brackets. Because of its length, I have split this into two parts.

The mind's 'Enigma machine', Daily Telegraph, 24 January 2006, Roger Highfield ... In all the ballyhoo that greeted the sequencing of the entire human genetic code, one inconvenient detail was often overlooked: scientists may have found that it takes 25,000 genes to build and run a human being, but they had no idea how these components worked together. [An important point. The statement that humans and chimps share ~98% of their genes is misleading in that it does not mention how those genes (and proteins and cells) work together as a unique system.]

Now a remarkable effort has shown how the proteins described by 200 of these genes make a fundamental piece of the machinery of thought, revealing the human brain is at least 1,000 times more powerful than previously estimated and providing profound new insights into mental illness. A working human brain is the most complex known object in the universe and weaves an average of a million connections every second between its 100 billion nerve cells. By one estimate, if you connected a Pentium 4 computer, each containing tens of millions of transistors, to every connection on the global internet, the average brain would still be 100 times more powerful. [This is a reductio ad absurdum of the Darwinist `blind watchmaker'! The Darwinists expect us to believe that a `blind watchmaker' could put together an "awesome chemical computer" (see next) that is "100 times more powerful" than "a Pentium 4 computer"!]

To reveal how genes build and run this awesome chemical computer, scientists in Cambridge and Edinburgh focused on the synapse, the junction through which nerve cells transmit information for the biological computations that underlie feeling, perception and thought. [Note "awesome chemical computer"! And note that the "genes [that] build and run this awesome chemical computer" must themselves form an even more "awesome chemical computer."]

The team broke down synapses into their component molecules and analysed them using a method called mass spectrometry, identifying more than 1,000 different proteins. Then the scientists found the genes that described them and studied which proteins interacted with each other. The effort revealed how 200 proteins worked together in a crucial molecular signalling machine that they christened MASC, unveiled in the latest issue of the journal Molecular Systems Biology. [And as Polanyi pointed out, "The manufacturing of a machine" goes beyond "the working of physical-chemical forces" and requires "the control of a non-physical-chemical principle by "a profoundly informative intervention" (my emphasis):

"We can now lend greater precision and force to the conclusion that morphological features are the boundary conditions of physical-chemical laws in living things and thus are not accountable by these laws, on which they rely for their functions. The functional structure of machines, products of man's designing and shaping, manifestly represent boundary conditions imposed on the laws of inanimate nature to press them into the service of a technical purpose. ... When this structure reappears in an organism, it is a configuration of particles that typifies a living being and serves its functions; at the same time, this configuration is a member of a large group of equally probable (and mostly meaningless) configurations. Such a highly improbable arrangement of particles is not shaped by the forces of physics or chemistry. It constitutes a boundary condition which as such transcends the laws of physics and transcends the laws of physics and chemistry. ... The manufacturing of a machine also represents a distinctive distribution of matter not due to the working of physical-chemical forces and it too, forms the characteristic boundary conditions of the system in question. We can see now more clearly why such a shaping of boundaries may he said to go beyond a mere fixing of boundaries and establishes a `controlling principle.' It achieves control of the boundaries by imprinting a significant pattern on the boundaries of the system. Or to use information language we may say that it puts the system under the control of a non-physical-chemical principle by a profoundly informative intervention." (Polanyi M., "Life Transcending Physics and Chemistry," Chemical & Engineering News, August 21, 1967, pp.54-66, p.64) ]
The team at the Wellcome Trust Sanger Institute and the University of Edinburgh believe it marks a new leap from genes to cognition, revealing how the MASC is in itself a chemical computer which further boosts the power of the brain by around 1,000 fold. [So without this "computer within a computer" (see below) the human brain would have an average IQ of 0.1! But then of course there would not be humans and in fact there would not even be mammals, because it is the mammalian brain they are talking about in the journal article. Indeed, it is going to be interesting to see how far back phylogenetically this "computer within a computer" goes. I suspect it could be present in all vertebrates, if not before (in fact further down Grant suggests that it may even predate nerve cells)! Conway-Morris notes that the brain of the most primitive `vertebrate' (actually chordate), amphioxus (Branchiostoma) already contains hidden within it "a template" for the "threefold division seen in the vertebrate brain of hind-, mid- and fore-sections" and therefore "carries the inherent potential for intelligence" of all vertebrates (including ours) hundreds of millions of years in advance of it being needed:
"Let us look, for example, at a much deeper stage in our evolution, effectively at the time of the ancestors of the fish. Enter the moderately undistinguished animal known as the lancelet worm or amphioxus (Branchiostoma and its relatives ..). By general agreement this beast is the nearest living approximation to the stage in evolution that preceded the fish, which in turn clambered on to land, moved to using the egg, grew fur, and in one lineage developed into socially alert arborealists. All these changes and shifts must have been accompanied by genetic changes, but if we look back to amphioxus we see a genetic architecture in place that seemingly has no obvious counterpart in its anatomy. To give just one example: the central nervous system of amphioxus is really rather simple. It consists of an elongate nerve cord stretching back along the body, above the precursor of the vertebral column (our backbone, consisting of a row of vertebrae) and a so-called brain. The brain can only be described as a disappointment. It is little more than an anterior swelling (it is called the cerebral vesicle) and has no obvious sign in terms of its morphology of even the beginnings of the characteristic threefold division seen in the vertebrate brain of hind-, mid- and fore-sections. Yet the molecular evidence, which is also backed up by some exquisitely fine studies of microanatomy suggests that, cryptically, the brain of amphioxus has regions equivalent to the tripartite division seen in the vertebrates. The clear implication of this is that folded within the seemingly simple brain of amphioxus is what can almost be described as a template for the equivalent organ of the vertebrates: in some sense amphioxus carries the inherent potential for intelligence. ... and its molecular inherency in any way unusual. Equally instructive examples can be culled from the most primitive animals, such as the sponges and Hydra (the latter is a relative of the sea- anemones and corals), in which genes (or proteins) that are essential for complex activities in more advanced animals are already present." (Conway Morris S., "Life's Solution: Inevitable Humans in a Lonely Universe," Cambridge University Press: New York NY, 2003, pp.6, 7)
That `blind watchmaker' sure is far-sighted! :-)]

"The synapse has far more computational power than we realised," said Prof Seth Grant of the Sanger, head of the mind machine team. [In other words, Darwinian `blind watchmaker' evolution did not predict it (not that that is unusual)!]

The discovery of a "computer within a computer" offers a new way to understand how information is processed in the brain. "We have uncovered a whole new layer of complexity," said Prof Grant. [And that is "complexity" that Darwinian `blind watchmaker' evolution has to account for!]

The MASC can turn patterns of activity generated by messenger chemicals called neurotransmitters into the changes in nerve cells that form memories. [So presumably without this "computer within a computer" there would not be memories (or at least not with anything like the power of the human memory)?]

It is like "the Enigma Machine of World War II, which was used to convert one code into another," said Prof Grant, who revealed its innards with Dr Andrew Pocklington, Dr Douglas Armstrong and Mr Mark Cumiskey. [It just gets better (or worse for Darwinian `blind watchmaker' evolution)! It sounds like we have yet another encoding and decoding system?]

"Our work could open up new ways to think about how the brain evolved, how it functions and how it is affected in disease," commented Prof Grant, explaining how the MASC seems to be a more basic and ancient unit of thinking than nerve cells. [If this is the case, then it will even more evidence for design by a far-sighted Watchmaker!]

"This machine - MASC - is built upon simple principles," he said. [All machines are "built upon simple principles." But principles don't of themselves build machines.]

[Continued in part #2]

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"

Friday, February 10, 2006

Re: would ... you assist me, as a fellow Christian, in understanding your views on creation further?

AN (copy to my blog CED minus your personal identifying information and minor changes)

----- Original Message -----
From: AN
To: Stephen E. Jones
Sent: Friday, February 10, 2006 1:29 AM
Subject: creation model

AN>Hi there,
>
>I'm aware that you asked me not to ask you another question (although I'm not certain why?) but if you have time I would please ask that you assist me, as a fellow Christian, in understanding your views on creation further?

I explained why I asked you not to send me any more private messages - I simply don't have the time to respond to them:

--------------------------------------------------------------------------- ---
----- Original Message -----
From: Stephen E. Jones
To: AN
Sent: Tuesday, September 20, 2005 9:43 PM
Subject: Re: questions about morton (sorry for the double)

[...]

I hope the above will help. However, if it doesn't, then there is nothing more that I can say. As I have said to you before, I don't have the time to respond to such private messages, so please don't send me any more. Thanks.

[...]
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I am writing a book, "Problems of Evolution", which, together with posting to my blog, takes up most of my free time.

AN>Maybe I've been too impersonal in the past so I'll give you a bit of background info. Basically I was raised in a non-practicing home. No one was an unbeliever that I was aware of, but yet when I came of age and started asking questions, nobody seemed to know anything and our Scriptural knowledge was abysmal. I've always been the questioning sort, so of course when time came I was nonstop in my search. I still don't know if this is a blessing or a curse.

Also, I cannot remember if it was you I said it to, but my advice is to not get fixated with Genesis, but start with the New Testament (which has a lot to say about creation). See my blog posts: "Ages of the patriarchs in Genesis 5 and 11" and "I am a Christian but am in a muddle over beliefs regarding origins".

In the end, there are basically three approaches in reconciling Genesis 1 with modern science:

1) Accept Genesis 1 literally and reject science (e.g. Young-Earth Creation);
2) Accept science and reject Genesis 1 (e.g. Liberal Christianity, non-Christianity); or
3) Accept both science and Genesis 1 non-literally (e.g. Old Earth Creation).

The choice is ours.

Even the atheist Darwinist philosopher Michael Ruse, in reviewing his fellow atheist Richard Dawkins' book, "A Devil's Chaplain" (2003), notes that "at least since the time of Saint Augustine (400 A.D.) Christians have been interpreting the seven days of creation metaphorically", so that is no excuse for Dawkins to reject Christianity because "Darwinism conflicts with the Book of Genesis taken literally":

"Also, I myself share just about every bit of Dawkins's nonbelief. ... However, I worry about the political consequences of Dawkins's message. If Darwinism is a major contributor to nonbelief, then should Darwinism be taught in publicly funded U.S. schools? ... It is true that Darwinism conflicts with the Book of Genesis taken literally, but at least since the time of Saint Augustine (400 A.D.) Christians have been interpreting the seven days of creation metaphorically. I would like to see Dawkins take Christianity as seriously as he undoubtedly expects Christianity to take Darwinism. I would also like to see him spell out fully the arguments as to the incompatibility of science (Darwinism especially) and religion (Christianity especially). So long as his understanding of Christianity remains at the sophomoric level, Dawkins does not deserve full attention." (Ruse M.E., "Through a Glass, Darkly." Review of "A Devil's Chaplain: Reflections on Hope, Lies, Science, and Love," by Richard Dawkins, Houghton Mifflin, 2003)

AN>You told me a long while back when I'd asked you about day 4, that you take G-1 as being broadly consecutive but into a framework also and this seems fair although I'm not 100% in understanding of that. Anyway my question is this if you have time or inclination:

I suggest you do what I did and read some good books on the topic, e.g. Blocher's "In the Beginning: The Opening Chapters of Genesis." There is also on line "Report of the Creation Study Committee" of the Presbyterian Church of America which considers the various Christian approaches to Genesis 1.

AN>How do we reconcile (regardless of view held) the statements in G-1 where it says the ocean existed prior to sky (1:2 vs day 2) when we know from modern findings that the early earth was hot and oceanless and oceans formed only after sky?

Quite clearly "sky" is not a scientific description, so I assume that God (the ultimate Author of both nature and Scripture) is telling us something right there! The leading evangelical theologian J.I. Packer makes a similar point:

"There are four opinions, basically, about the seven days. The first is the literalist hypothesis which maintains that what we are reading about is twenty-four-hour days by our clocks; what we are being told in Genesis 1 is that the whole world came to be formed within what we would recognize as a working week. The hypothesis assumes that what we have in Genesis is descriptive prose, of newspaper type. The second view is that each of the days of the creation is an allegorical figure. What each of the references to the evening and the morning represent is a geological epoch, a very, very long period of time, hundreds of thousands of years at least. There has been much effort in this century by those who have understood the days this way to try and show that the order of things in Genesis 1 corresponds to the best scientific account that can be given of how specific items emerged and took their place in the order of the world. A witty Roman Catholic writer described this method of understanding as an attempt to raise Moses' credit by giving him a B.Sc. Those who take this 'concordist' view, as it is called, assume that part of the purpose of Genesis 1 was to give us scientific information about the stages by which things came to be. Third is what is called the revelation day theory, which takes the six evenings and mornings as signifying that creation was revealed in a story with six instalments, each instalment being given to the inspired writer on a separate day. After the first instalment had been given, the writer said there was evening and there was morning. That is a way of saying that God gave him the next bit of the story the next day. Fourth there is the so-called framework view, sometimes called the literary hypothesis. This view says that the six days, evening and morning, are part of what we may call a prose poem, that is a total pictorial presentation of the fact of creation in the form of a story of a week's work. Without going into the details of argument about these different views, let me tell you straightaway that in my judgement this fourth view is the only viable one. Why? Because in this account light appears on the first day while God only makes the sun and the moon and the stars on the fourth day. That fact alone, it seems to me, shows that what we have here is not anything that can be called science, but rather an imaginative pattern of order replacing chaos ..." (Packer J.I., "Honouring the Written Word of God: The Collected Shorter Writings of James I. Packer," Vol. 3, Paternoster Press: Carlisle UK, 1999, p.179)

Mind you, if someone wanted to be concordistic, he could claim that "sky" is equivalent to the atmosphere and then argue (correctly) that on the early Earth the atmosphere came before the ocean!

AN>If you have any illumination here I would be grateful,
>God bless,
>AN

I advised a Christian who asked me similar questions (maybe it was you?), that I went through a spiritual/mid-life crisis in the early 1990's and used to walk at night listening to Chuck Swindoll on the radio. One night he said that we all need a mentor, but if we don't have one (as I didn't), then Jesus could be our mentor. I resolved there and then to read through the New Testament only the words of Jesus in my morning quiet time, confessing where I fell short and praying that the Lord would help me to apply his words to my life. It took me ~8 years and it changed my life forever. I recommend you put Genesis 1 aside and do that first, then go back to Genesis ~8 years later. You will then see it (and everything) in its right perspective.

We who claim to be a Christians need to consider Jesus' criticism of the super-religious Pharisees of his day, for having "neglected the more important matters of the law-justice, mercy and faithfulness" (my emphasis):

Matthew 23:23 "Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites! You give a tenth of your spices-mint, dill and cummin. But you have neglected the more important matters of the law-justice, mercy and faithfulness. You should have practiced the latter, without neglecting the former."

Just substitute "spend most of your Bible study time on trying to reconcile Genesis 1 with modern science" for "give a tenth of your spices-mint, dill and cummin" and you will have a fair idea of what Jesus probably thinks of modern Christians who are fixated on Genesis 1 at the expense of the rest of the Bible.

Now I have again given you my advice. So please do not send me any more private messages. I am sorry, but I simply don't have the time to answer them. If you follow my advice, it will largely resolve your problems (and not just with Genesis). But if you don't want to follow my advice, then why ask me for it?

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"

Thursday, February 09, 2006

My critique of Darwin's Origin of Species, p.5

As part of writing the first draft of Chapter 4, "History ... Darwin," of my book, "Problems of Evolution," I have decided to skim through Darwin's Origin of Species (6th edition, 1872) noting problems in it. I considered saving these problems to a file or web page, but then I thought of posting these pages to my blog. This way it could be useful to others and might generate some constructive feedback (although as usual I won't have the time to debate at any length comments received). I will use the British Library's webbed version, which preserves the pagination of the original.

Here is my critique of the first page (page 5), ignoring Darwin's Historical Sketch and Introduction, since I want to concentrate on Darwin's actual theory. My comments are bold and in square brackets. They will usually be brief and unreferenced, and will serve as points to address in more detail in my book (although the sheer number of them will mean I can only include the most significant).


[page] 5 CHAPTER I. VARIATION UNDER DOMESTICATION. [...]

Causes of Variability.

WHEN we compare the individuals of the same variety or sub-variety of our older cultivated plants and animals, one of the first points which strikes us is, that they generally differ more from each other than do the individuals of any one species or variety in a state of nature. [Is this true? What detailed comparisons did Darwin make? What criteria did he use? Since "cultivated plants and animals" are a tiny subset of "species ... in a state of nature," how statistically valid is the comparison? Also, since most cultivated plants are polyploids, which have little (if anything) to do with the Darwinian natural selection of random micromutations (NSRM). So how relevant is this to Darwin's argument, given that Neo-Darwinists (like botanist Stebbins, a co-founder of the Neo-Darwinian modern synthesis) have rightly tended to downplay the evolutionary importance of polyploidy:

"Polyploidy is a very common method of evolution in higher plants. Between one-fourth and one-third of the species of flowering plants are polyploid with reference to their nearest relatives. Familiar examples among crop plants are wheat, oats, potato, tobacco, cotton, alfalfa, and most species of pasture grasses. Familiar weeds and wild flowers which are polyploid are the eastern blue flag (Iris versicolor), meadow rue (Thalictrum spp.), some species of wild rose, chickweed (Stellaria media), miner's lettuce (Montia perfoliata), yarrow (Achillea spp.), and various species of violets and asters. Furthermore, there is evidence that polyploidy in the remote past has given rise to many genera and groups of genera such as the apples, olives, willows, poplars, and many genera of ferns. Nevertheless, polyploidy has contributed little to progressive evolution. In genera which contain both diploids and polyploids, the major trends of evolution are all represented by diploid species, and the polyploids serve merely to multiply the variations on certain particular adaptive `themes.' This is probably because the large amount of gene duplication dilutes the effects of new mutations and gene combinations to such an extent that polyploids have great difficulty evolving truly new adaptive gene complexes." (Stebbins G.L., "Processes of Organic Evolution," Prentice-Hall: Englewood Cliffs NJ, 1966, Second printing, p.129)]

And if we reflect on the vast diversity of the plants and animals which have been cultivated, and which have varied during all ages under the most different climates and treatment, [How could Darwin know this? Is it even true? The range of "plants and animals" humans cultivate is actually quite narrow.] we are driven to conclude that this great variability is due to our domestic productions having been raised under conditions of life not so uniform as, and somewhat different from, those to which the parent species had been exposed under nature. [Again, is this true? Tropical fruit is usually cultivated in the tropics, unless grown in glasshouses, etc.]

There is, also, some probability in the view propounded by Andrew Knight, that this variability may be partly connected with excess of food. It seems clear that organic beings must be exposed during several generations to new conditions to cause any great amount of variation; [Is this true?] and that, when the organisation has once begun to vary, it generally continues varying for many generations. [In what sense does it vary? Is the variation cyclical or linear? How long is "many generations"? For what is supposed to be a major scientific theory, Darwin's argument here has a vague, unfalsifiable, `how long is a piece of string?', quality!] No case is on record of a variable organism ceasing to vary under cultivation. [Is this true? Or if it is true, do not the variations tend to become increasingly minor and then oscillate around a mean? What about the leading plant breeder Luther Burbank's "law ... of the Reversion to the Average"?:

"There is a law ... of the Reversion to the Average. I know from my experience that I can develop a plum half an inch long or one 2 ½ inches long, with every possible length in between, but I am willing to admit that it is hopeless to try to get a plum the size of a small pea, or one as big as a grapefruit. I have daisies on my farms little larger than my fingernail and some that measure six inches across, but I have none as big as a sunflower, and never expect to have. I have roses that bloom pretty steadily for six months in the year, but I have none that will bloom twelve, and I will not have. In short, there are limits to the development possible, and these limits follow a law. But what law, and why? It is the law that I have referred to above. Experiments carried on extensively have given us scientific proof of what we had already guessed by observation; namely, that plants and animals all tend to revert, in successive generations, toward a given mean or average. Men grow to be seven feet tall, and over, but never to ten; there are dwarfs not higher than 24 inches, but none that you can carry in your hand. ... In short, there is undoubtedly a pull toward the mean which keeps all living things within some more or less fixed limitations." (Burbank L., in Hall W., ed., "Partner of Nature," AppletonCentury, 1939, pp.98-99, in Macbeth N., "Darwin Retried: An Appeal to Reason," Gambit: Boston MA, 1971, p.36. Ellipses Macbeth's)]

Our oldest cultivated plants, such as wheat, still yield new varieties: [Wheat is another polyploid, in fact a hexaploid , i.e. the result of a hybridisation between two ancestral grass species (2n=14), then doubling of the hybrid's entire genome (2n=28), then a further hybridisation with another species (n=14 + n=7 = 2n=21), and then another genome doubling (2n=42), so it is not an example of the selection (leaving aside for the moment the difference between selection by an intelligent human designer and selection by a `blind watchmaker') of micromutations.] our oldest domesticated animals are still capable of rapid improvement or modification. [Again, is this true? If they were "capable of rapid improvement or modification" then it would have happened already in the thousands of years that humans have been selectively breeding "our oldest domesticated animals"! The very fact that modern science has had to employ not only intelligent design, in the form of selective breeding, but advanced intelligent design, in the form of genetic and cellular modifications, using the knowledge and techniques of modern molecular biology to obtain further "improvement or modification," also argues against Darwin's claim.]

[Continued at pp.5-6]

This critique of just one page of Darwin's Origin of Species has taken me longer than I expected. I only hope Darwin did not have so many questionable claims in the subsequent 423 (pages 6-429) pages! Because even at a page a day, this could take over a year, I will continue through the rest of my book's first draft and catch up with the section on Darwin's Origin of Species later.

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"

Tuesday, February 07, 2006

Scientists Find Ability For Grammar Hardwired Into Humans

A news item about a study further confirming that humans are hardwired with a universal grammar (I have used the actual University of Rochester's press release heading). My comments are bold and in square brackets.

Brains built for grammar: study, CBC, 6 Feb 2006 ... The properties of grammar may be hard-wired in our brains, according to a study of people who are deaf and isolated from conventional language. Young children normally learn language through exposure to a spoken or signed language, as well as their innate abilities to acquire certain types of language patterns. To tease out the effect of each influence, researchers turn to people who aren't exposed to conventional language. For three years, researchers at the University of Rochester studied three young men in Nicaragua who were completely deaf since birth. The men had no exposure to formal sign language, never had contact with another signer and weren't exposed to written Spanish in school. Nevertheless, the boys developed a unique form of gesture communication. "Our findings suggest that certain fundamental characteristics of human language systems appear in gestural communication, even when the user has never been exposed to linguistic input and has not descended from previous generations of skilled communicative partners," said Elissa Newport, a professor of brain and cognitive sciences and linguistics. Newport and her colleagues found the signers used the same rules of grammar as other users of language, such as the grammatical concept of a "subject." The signers were tested by watching 66 short videos of actions, such as a woman walking. Researchers asked the boys to explain what they had seen in their own sign language. The findings suggest the "grammatical concept of 'subject' is part of the bedrock in which languages form," Newport said. The study appears in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences. ... [See also EurekAlert! & Science Daily.

Darwin theorised that human language was just "the imitation and modification of ... the voices of other animals":

"With respect to the origin of articulate language ... I cannot doubt that language owes its origin to the imitation and modification of various natural sounds, the voices of other animals, and man's own instinctive cries, aided by signs and gestures." (Darwin C.R., "The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex," [1871], John Murray: London, Second Edition, 1922, reprint, p.135)

But in fact, as the Darwinist linguist Pinker points out, it is a completely different system:

"Language is ... different from other animals' communication systems ... Nonhuman communication systems are based on one of three designs: a finite repertory of calls ..., a continuous analog signal that registers the magnitude of some state ... or a series of random variations on a theme .... As we have seen, human language has a very different design. The discrete combinatorial system called `grammar' makes human language infinite ..., digital ..., and compositional ... "Even the seat of human language in the brain is special. The vocal calls of primates are controlled not by their cerebral cortex but by phylogenetically older neural structures in the brain stem and limbic system ... Human vocalizations other than language, like sobbing, laughing, moaning, and shouting in pain, are also controlled subcortically. ... Genuine language ... is seated in the cerebral cortex ..." (Pinker S., "The Language Instinct: The New Science of Language and Mind," [1994], Penguin: London, 2000, reprint, pp.365-366)

I have added this to my "Problems of Evolution" book outline, PE 14. 1.7.1."Man ... Uniqueness ... Language ... Universal grammar hardwired"]

PS: Another quote below by early design theorist Robert E.D. Clark on the so-called `God of the gaps'.

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"


"Let us look more closely at this point of view. If you discover a `God of the gaps', we are told, not only will He be doomed to be squeezed out of existence as the gaps close, but even before that happens He will be a mere hypothesis and therefore useless for religion. Imagine the psychological state of the young man who pins his faith on a hypothesis that may lose its usefulness overnight! Moreover, this God-or rather this hypothesis-will be an enemy to science, for the notion that God resides in a gap will encourage religious people to frighten off scientists with notices of `trespassers will be prosecuted'. For it is impertinent to investigate God by scientific means.... In short, according to the theologians who raise these objections, we must look for God everywhere or nowhere and, according to agnostics and atheists we must look for Him nowhere. The analogy of radioactivity shows how poor this argument is. Early workers did not accept the mutability of atoms because there was a gap in man's knowledge concerning certain rare minerals. The evidence was positive, not negative. There was definite concrete evidence-it was found, of course, in one of the `gaps' in contemporary science (where else could it be found?)-that supposedly changeless elements did in fact change. ... No reasonable person is interested in gaps for their own sake. Christians of a former generation are sometimes ridiculed today for their outmoded belief in the `God of the gaps', but did they, in fact, even in their wilder moments, ever really argue that whatever could not be explained by science was due to God? One may doubt it. Mankind has known for thousands of years that lime gets hot with water (St. Augustine mentions the fact) and that metals change their colours in sulphide solutions, but not till recent times did anyone know why. It was never argued that these gaps in knowledge were a proof that God was performing miracles! Christians in the nineteenth century had not the slightest idea why a strange red spot appeared on Jupiter in 1878 or why there was sometimes a green flash when the sun was setting over the ocean, but they did not account for these rare events in terms of Divine intervention. Mere lack of understanding is not and never has been a reason for seeking a theological explanation. The `God of the gaps' is a modern myth.' Christians have often supposed that they had positive evidence for belief in God, and they have sometimes found (or thought they found) the evidence in `gaps'. But again, where else could they have found it? In like manner the Becquerels, Curies, Rutherfords and Soddys of half a century ago looked for positive evidence of the existence of a new kind of energy. It was not gaps in knowledge per se which interested them. They did not point to Jupiter's spot or the green flash." (Clark R.E.D., "The Universe: Plan or Accident?: The Religious Implications of Modern Science," [1949], Paternoster: London, Third Edition, 1961, pp.10-12. Emphasis in original)

Monday, February 06, 2006

Marsupial's genome sequenced ... produces surprise immune finding

News items about surprises following the sequencing of the first marsupial genome, that of the South American opossum (Monodelphis domestica). My comments are bold and in square brackets.

Marsupial's genome sequenced: Genome research produces surprise immune finding, ABC, January 31, 2006, Judy Skatssoon ... Australian researchers have helped document the genetic code of a marsupial for the first time, with the sequencing of the opossum genome. The sequencing of the first marsupial genome has allowed researchers to trace the immune system of mammals back to what they have dubbed an ancestral "immune supercomplex". University of Sydney evolutionary biologist Kathy Belov, who led the international team, said the research suggested that the human immune system in its present form was a surprisingly recent innovation. The grey short-tailed opossum (Monodelphis domestica), found in South America, is the first marsupial to have its genome sequenced. The sequencing was done at the Broad Institute in the US and the current research represents the first gene cluster characterised. Dr Belov and colleagues from Australia, Europe and the US report their research on the region, known as the major histocompatibility complex (MHC), in the journal PLoS Biology today. "The research has helped form a picture of what that region would have looked like in ancestral mammals," Dr Belov said. That picture shows a central complex of immune genes that have since dispersed and are now scattered around a variety of chromosomes. "We're finding that the opossum has a couple of genes in their MHC which aren't in the MHC of other species, and other species have genes in their MHC which aren't in other species," she said. "By tracing it back we can see that originally there was this big cluster of immune genes ... and over time those genes have moved out of this central complex. "It suggests there was one big immune gene supercomplex in a mammalian ancestor. "It's a bit like a dinosaur in that we only know that it's around from the fossil evidence." ... Dr Belov will also examine the MHC in the platypus, the first monotreme, or egg-laying mammal, to have its genome sequenced. ... It is believed that the first monotreme appeared about 210 million years ago and marsupial and placental mammalian lineages separated around 180 million years ago. South American and Australian marsupials split about 70 million years ago with the break up of the southern supercontinent Gondwana, and continued to evolve separately. Today, the South American and Australian groups are about as different as humans and mice, Dr Belov says. Dr Belov says birds and other non-mammals have a relatively simple MHC whereas in placental mammals it is much more complex. "Marsupial MHC turns out be intermediate," she said. This suggests that "there's been some major changes [in the human immune system] that have gone on quite recently and they're probably more recent than a lot of people expected". ... A project to sequence the genome of Australia's tammar wallaby ... will complement work on the opossum ... "If we have the tammar wallaby sequence and the opossum sequence we can pretty much predict the sequences of all the other marsupials", she said. ...

Genome research produces surprise immune finding, ABC, January 31, 2006, Judy Skatssoon ... Australian researchers have helped document the genetic code of a marsupial for the first time, with the sequencing of the opossum genome. The sequencing of the first marsupial genome has allowed researchers to trace the immune system of mammals back to what they have dubbed an ancestral "immune supercomplex". University of Sydney evolutionary biologist Kathy Belov, who led the international team, said the research suggested that ... [This indicates that the common ancestor of all mammals was special ("... there was one big immune gene supercomplex in a mammalian ancestor"); and that so are humans ("there's been some major changes [in the human immune system] that have gone on quite recently and they're probably more recent than a lot of people expected" and "the human immune system in its present form was a surprisingly recent innovation" Another finding of modern science that doesn't sound very Darwinian!]

PS: I was today reading the book, "The Universe: Plan or Accident?" (1961) by British Christian chemist, the late Robert E.D. Clark (1906-1984). I bought and read the book in 1969, and it was brought home to me again today how much he anticipated the arguments of the ID movement, yet it appears the founders of same were not aware of Clark's writings? So as to make them more widely known, I will try to include a quote from Clark's book at the very end of my posts (as a sort of `tagline'), although it will be a coincidence if it has anything to do with the topic. See below is the first quote, about the so-called "God-of-the-gaps," which Theistic Evolutionists in particular invoke as a mantra, to ward off evidence for God's supernatural intervention in natural history

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"


"If we would relate science to philosophy or religious belief, it is argued, we must not seek for the meaning of the abnormal, the extraordinary, or that which does not fall in with our expectations, because, if we do so, science will soon catch up with us. And then what shall we do? Hunt for something else that science cannot explain-and shift from that in turn to something else, and so on endlessly, like a cat chasing its own tail? This argument is commonly used with reference to God ... When believers use such argument in order to reach the conclusion that God exists, the God they discover, or think they discover, is disdainfully dismissed as a `God of the gaps'-the `gaps' referred to being gaps in knowledge. Here in this common argument we discern a disingenuous denial of the scientific method. For the scientist does not think in terms of gaps at all-if he did he would soon lose interest in his science. So-called gaps may, of course, turn out to be gaps and no more than gaps, but if so they lose their interest and are forgotten. The scientist lives in the hope that, on investigation, they will turn out to be gaps pregnant with meaning: he is on the look-out, not for something negative, but for something positive; something that will show that a new principle is at work in nature; something that will create interest among his fellow scientists. Comparison with the early days of radioactivity is here peculiarly apt. When Pierre and Madame Curie and, later, Rutherford were seeking to focus scientific attention upon the curious properties of radium, many scientists, among them Armstrong the chemist, argued that radium was a little peculiar, perhaps, but nothing to become excited about. The recognized principles of science, it was argued, would soon explain the few phenomena in connexion with radium that could not yet be explained-if, indeed, there were any of importance. Radium was luminous, it was true, but not as brightly so as some materials: it discharged an electroscope, but so did quinine sulphate. It was foolish to postulate an entirely new principle in science on the basis of a mere gap in our knowledge which would, no doubt, be filled in due course. Now this is exactly the attitude of many modern writers on science and religion. Nor is the attitude confined to agnostics and atheists; it is to be found, too, among theologians. Both parties insist that philosophical inquiry into the fundamental gaps in scientific knowledge is unjustified." (Clark R.E.D., "The Universe: Plan or Accident?: The Religious Implications of Modern Science," [1949], Paternoster: London, Third edition, 1961, pp.8-10. Emphasis in original)

Sunday, February 05, 2006

The Problem with God: Interview with Richard Dawkins #8

The Problem with God: Interview with Richard Dawkins, Beliefnet, 15 December 2005 The renowned biologist talks about intelligent design, dishonest Christians, and why God is no better than an imaginary friend. Interview by Laura Sheahen. ...

Continued from part #7 with my comments bold and in square brackets and the interviewer's questions bold and in italics.

Are there one or two phrases you've heard repeatedly quoted out of context that you'd like to set the record straight about?

Well, that's one of them, about the Cambrian Explosion. [See part #7 where Dawkins was not quoted out of context.]

Another one is Darwin's famous phrase, to suppose that "the eye, with all its inimitable contrivances"-he goes on about the complications of the eye-"could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest degree." [Again, Darwin did say it:

"To suppose that the eye with all its inimitable contrivances for adjusting the focus to different distances, for admitting different amounts of light, and for the correction of spherical and chromatic aberration, could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest degree." (Darwin C.R., "The Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection," [1872], Everyman's Library, J.M. Dent & Sons: London, 6th Edition, 1928, reprint, p.167)]

He then goes on to explain it, and they never quote that. They just stop there. [This is false on two counts: 1) Darwin does not go on to explain it (how "the eye with all its inimitable contrivances ... could have been formed by natural selection" (my emphasis); and 2) I for one have quoted the fuller quote, continuing from the above:

"When it was first said that the sun stood still and the world turned round, the common sense of mankind declared the doctrine false; but the old saying of `Vox populi, vox Dei.' as every philosopher knows, cannot be trusted in science. Reason tells me, that if numerous gradations from a simple and imperfect eye to one complex and perfect can be shown to exist, each grade being useful to its possessor, as is certainly the case; if, further, the eye ever varies and the variations be inherited, as is likewise certainly the case; and if such variations should be useful to any animal under changing conditions of life, then the difficulty of believing that a perfect and complex eye could be formed by natural selection, though insuperable by our imagination, should not be considered as subversive of the theory." (Darwin," 1872, p.167)

For example, see in my "Problems of Evolution" book outline, PE 13.2.2.4 "Eye ... Gradations due to limitations of natural selection." I also quoted it in full on my now terminated list CED at least twice, e.g. Mar 20, 2005; Mar 19, 2005. I had also critiqued Darwin's entire argument on the eye, first on an evolution-run list Jan 8, 2001 #1 and #2 and then on my list CED, Mar 27, 2001 1/2 and 2/2.]

Dishonest. [Actually, if anyone is "dishonest" it is Dawkins (or else deluded), for giving the impression that Darwin, in his Origin of Species, "goes on to explain it," i.e. how "the eye with all its inimitable contrivances ... could have been formed by natural selection" (my emphasis), when he does not. Darwin (and presumably his devoted disciple Dawkins) must know that privately Darwin himself was not convinced by his own argument, and nor were his scientific colleagues. For example, Harvard's Asa Gray, responding to a complimentary copy of the Origin of Species that Darwin sent him, considered that Darwin's "attempt to account for the formation of ... eyes ... by natural selection" to be "the weakest point in the book" and Darwin agreed:

"Well, what seems to me the weakest point in the book is the attempt to account for the formation of organs, the making of eyes, &c., by natural selection." [Gray A., letter to Darwin C.R., January 23rd, 1860] "...About the weak points I agree. The eye to this day gives me a cold shudder, but when I think of the fine known gradations, my reason tells me I ought to conquer the cold shudder." [Darwin C.R., letter to Asa Gray, February, 1860] (Darwin F., ed., "The Life and Letters of Charles Darwin," [1898], Basic Books: New York NY, Vol. II., 1959, reprint, pp.66,67)

I will update my critique of Darwin's explanation (so-called) of the eye in a future post. In the meantime, here are some quotes on the problem of the eye for Darwinism, which I don't think I have posted anywhere previously:

"... the theory of evolution assumes that the most complicated eye, for example, that of an eagle or a man, started as a freckle or light-sensitive spot which was gradually transformed by chance in upward stages, eventually becoming a working, purposeful, complex mechanism with millions of parts. It is assumed that the light-sensitive cells were slowly folded inward to form, progressively, a retina. The skin on the surface then became transparent and turned into a lens to focus light on to the retina. Consider the eye 'with all its inimitable contrivances', as Darwin called them, which can admit different amounts of light, focus at different distances, and correct spherical and chromatic aberration. Consider the retina, consisting of 150 million correctly made and positioned specialized cells. These are the rods and cones. Consider the nature of light-sensitive retinal. Combined with a protein (opsin) retinal becomes a chemical switch. Triggered by light, this switch can generate a nerve impulse. Retinal is an archetypal molecule, a foundation for visual sense. Each switch-containing rod and cone is correctly wired to the brain so that the electrical storm (an estimated 1000 million impulses per second) is continuously monitored and translated, by a step which is a total mystery, into a mental picture. Who, we ask, is the ghost in the machine experiencing this phenomenal image? Who are you, the seer behind the rearrangement of light?" (Pitman M., "Adam and Evolution," Rider & Co: London, 1984, p.215 )
"Evolutionists employ the veil of time to blur their vision. The story starts with a light-sensitive spot, such as is found in Euglena; a series of broad but superficial strokes culminate in the complex eye of an octopus, or the even more complex vertebrate eye which is yours. But a list of eyes from various animals, not necessarily related, no more demonstrates evolution than a carefully ordered range of lamps. " (Pitman, 1984, pp.215-216 )
"Darwin said: 'If it could be demonstrated that any complex organ existed, which could not possibly have been formed by numerous, successive, slight modifications, my theory would absolutely break down.' The eye is a good contender. Suppose that a light-spot remained at the bottom of a cup-shaped organ and a lens formed at the top. A nerve fibre then connected the light-spot with the brain and the cup became elongated so that it could only respond to light coming from a particular direction, as if someone were looking down a tube. The compound eyes of insects consist of a very large number of these organs, called ommatidia, grouped together. The optical images are assembled from dots, each dot from an ommatidium, somewhat as a TV picture is assembled from many light and dark dots. The picture is composite. There is the problem of how a group of ommatidia get together to make an eye." (Pitman, 1984, p.216 )
"But what about colour vision? It is found in several bony fishes, reptiles, birds, bees and primates. Among mammals only primates see in colour. Dogs, cats, horses and bulls do not. Fish supposedly evolved the necessary retinal cones to give them colour vision, but then lost them. 'Re-evolved' by certain unrelated birds and reptiles, they were lost by mammals, but by luck 're-surfaced' in primates. An odd story indeed. Given such a diverse 'mosaic' spread, it is reasonable to assume the subtheme (colour vision) is coded, something like an 'optional extra', onto the main visual theme. Such permutations as we find could arise by this adaptation. A more likely story? Creationists think so; at least it is plausible." (Pitman, 1984, p.216 )
"An eye, like a television or camera, exists to attain an end - sight. It is teleological. All types of eye, based on the light-sensitive cell, are simply variations on the coupled theme of optical-image perception and interpretation. Both faculties are required; each is useless without the other. Eye, sight and meaning are inextricably entwined. It is reasonable to argue that, just as a film camera is unthinkable without purpose and intelligent information embodied in it, so an eye is the product of concept, not chance. That such an instrument should undergo a succession of blind but lucky accidents which by necessity led to perfect sight is as credible as if all the letters of The Origin of Species, being placed in a box, shaken and poured out, should at last come together in the order in which they occur in that diverting work." (Pitman, 1984, p.216 )
"The vertebrate eye is, in principle, quite different from the compound eye. The image is 'simple', uniform and inverted like that of a camera. How could this type of eye have developed from the normal invertebrate type? It is no use invoking cephalopod molluscs, like the octopus and squid, whose eyes bear striking similarities to our own. They are genetically unrelated and no series, leading up to their extraordinary optical apparatus (in some ways excelling our own), exists. A squid can distinguish polarized light, which we cannot, and their retinas have a finer structure which almost certainly means they can distinguish finer detail than us." (Pitman, 1984, pp.216-217 )
"Two sorts of eye are required. A very small eye, suitable for an insect but built in a manner similar to that of a man's eye would not work because it would not be able to diffract the light enough. Its possessor would scarcely be able to make out the shape of objects at all. Conversely, it seems that a much magnified compound eye would prove vastly inferior to an eye having lens and retina. There is teleological necessity for the two designs. But how did an eye or two arise? There is no evidence for any transitional form, even if one were feasible. We are not treated to a detailed account of the evolution of retina, cornea, rods and cones, visual photochemistry, tears ducts, lids, muscles etc. Can such an irrational and hollow hypothesis be called scientific? What advantage, as far as natural selection is concerned, could accrue from the starting of an eye when the materials forming it were not yet transparent. In the human, coding generates biconvex lenses, purposely free from blood vessels, and focusing apparatus which is exquisitely refined." (Pitman, 1984, p.217 )
"Of what survival value is a lens, forming an image, if not intimately linked to a nervous system which will translate that image into electrical form? Or a nerve without a brain to interpret the data? How could a visual nervous system have evolved before there was an eye to give it information? So questions continue until all parts of the body are woven into a single whole, a web of mutual necessity." (Pitman, 1984, p.217 )
"Darwinism does not look you squarely in the eye. It insists on faith in the unseen conversion of one type of eye into another. Upon this faith a humble shrimp imposes considerable strain. Moths, fireflies and Euphausiid shrimps, creatures all active in the dark, have special compound eyes which include a retina on which the multiple lenses focus at a common point to form an upright image. These shrimps, which seem to be, and are, classified as close 'cousins' to true shrimps, employ lens cylinders which smoothly bend the incoming light so that it all focuses at a common point, rather than forming multiple images as most compound eyes do. This feat of optical engineering has only been duplicated by humans in the last decade." (Pitman, 1984, p.217 )
"If this were not enough, Michael Land, a biologist from Sussex University, has observed that other shrimps have eyes which employ a different principle of physics, reflection from mirrors. The eyes have squared facets employed as radially arranged mirrors. It requires precise geometry to align such mirrors so that incoming rays are all reflected to focus at a common point, forming an image there. In an article entitled 'Nature as an Optical Engineer' Dr Land wrote: `I would guess that a refracting optical system, with refractive index crystalline cones, could not evolve into a reflecting system with squared multilayer-coated surfaces, nor vice versa. Both are successful and very sophisticated image-forming devices, but I cannot imagine an intermediate form that would work at all.' [Land, M., "Nature as an Optical Engineer," New Scientist, Vol. 84, No. 1175, October 1979, p.13] No common ancestors or series, leading up to these two very different sorts of eyes in the same shrimp-like body, are known. Confronted with the evidence, I believe a reasonable Mr. Darwin would have opted for a theory of design. Over one hundred years ago he wrote: `To suppose that the eye ... could have been formed by natural selection, seems, I freely confess, absurd in the highest degree.'" (Pitman, 1984, p.218)]

[End! See parts #1, #2, #3, #4, #5, #6, #7]

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"

Britons unconvinced on evolution #2

Britons unconvinced on evolution, BBC, 26 January 2006 ...

Continued from part #1. My comments are bold and in square brackets.

The findings prompted surprise from the scientific community. Lord Martin Rees, President of the Royal Society, said: "It is surprising that many should still be sceptical of Darwinian evolution. Darwin proposed his theory nearly 150 years ago, and it is now supported by an immense weight of evidence. [Rees is just deluding himself. The "immense weight of evidence" for "Darwinian evolution" is all microevolution. There is little, if any, evidence that "Darwinian evolution," i.e. the natural selection of random micromutations, was responsible for major changes (macroevolution) in life's history. Indeed there is positive evidence against it, e.g. the fossil record does not (and never has) been a good fit to Darwinian theory, as one of the world's leading paleontologists, Robert L. Carroll, points out:

"The most graphic demonstration of the inadequacy of Darwin's hypothesis of the constancy of evolutionary patterns over all time scales can be seen by comparing his hypothetical representation of the patterns of evolution for both very short and very long periods of time with the patterns of evolution that have since been reconstructed on the basis of the fossil record of multicellular plants and animals over the past 500 million years (Figs. 1.2-1.4). The diagram used by Darwin to illustrate evolution both at the level of populations and species and over the vast expanse of geological time is characterized by gradual and continuous change. Most populations within species, or families with in orders, diverge progressively. Some lineages continue with little change, but most eventually become extinct. The entire adaptive space is occupied by the groups diagramed, and the rate of change, indicated by the slope of the lines, remains fairly constant. The patterns established from the fossil record of the major groups of vascular plants, vertebrates, and nonvertebrate metazoans are conspicuously different. There are relatively few major lineages, all of which are very distinct from one an other. Gaps between the lineages indicate that adaptive space is not fully occupied. Instead of showing gradual and continuous change through time, the major lineages appear suddenly in the fossil record, already exhibiting many of the features by which their modern representatives are recognized. It must be assumed that evolution occurs much more rapidly between groups than within groups. For most of their evolutionary history, fundamental aspects of the anatomy and way of life of these lineages do not change significantly. Very few intermediates between groups are known from the fossil record." (Carroll R.L., "Patterns and Processes of Vertebrate Evolution," Cambridge University Press: Cambridge UK, 1997, pp.2, 4. My emphasis)]

"We are, however, fortunate compared to the US in that no major segment of UK religious or cultural life opposes the inclusion of evolution in the school science curriculum." ... [Again Rees is deluding himself. There is no major segment of US religious or cultural life that opposes the inclusion of evolution in the school science curriculum either. Since at least the 1980s (if not before) the emphasis of both major creationist and ID groups has been that both evolution and its alternatives be taught in the school science curriculum. In particular, the ID movement's publicly stated position is "Teach the Controversy,", i.e. "... teach the scientific controversy about Darwinian evolution. Teachers should teach students about the main scientific arguments for and against Darwinian theory."]

Four out of 10 say science classes should include intelligent design, The Guardian, James Randerson, January 26, 2006 ... Four out of 10 people in the UK think that religious alternatives to Darwin's theory of evolution should be taught as science in schools, according to a BBC poll. [That's a nice headline! But the definition of "intelligent design theory" was wrong, being "that certain features of living things are best explained by the intervention of a supernatural being, e.g. God" which is not what the ID movement claims that ID is. And ID is not a "religious alternative to Darwin's theory," it is a secular scientific theory, based solely on the evidence of nature and countering the claim of Darwin's theory that the evident design of living things is just an illusion:

Natural selection is the blind watchmaker, blind because it does not see ahead, does not plan consequences, has no purpose in view. Yet the living results of natural selection overwhelmingly impress us with the appearance of design as if by a master watchmaker, impress us with the illusion of design and planning." (Dawkins R., "The Blind Watchmaker: Why the Evidence of Evolution Reveals a Universe Without Design," W.W Norton & Co: New York NY, 1986.21)]

The natural history broadcaster Sir David Attenborough said scientists should defend the boundary between science and religion: "Science teachers know perfectly well that science is based on evidence and that intelligent design is not based on evidence - in fact, quite the reverse." [Attenborough is deluding himself too. The Darwinists problem is that the longer they keep on saying things that the public increasingly know are false, the worse they make it for their case.]

Intelligent design (ID) is the notion that some structures within cells are too complicated to have just evolved and must have been placed there by a divine creator. [Again this is false. ID says nothing about "a divine creator." All that ID says is that there are certain features of the natural world that theinference to the best explanation is that they were not produced solely by unintelligent causes, but at least partly by intelligent cause(s). ]

"That is not a scientific statement," said Sir David. [This is the usual Darwinist word-game with "scientific" and "science". The only issue is whether intelligent design is true.]

"If you inject that into science classes you are denying the very intellectual processes that you are supposed to be teaching as part of science." [The simple fact is that if it is "science" for Darwinists like Dawkins to claim that there is no design in nature, then it is also "science" to claim that there is design in nature. I have added this to my work-in-progress ID FAQ.]

When asked what should be taught in science classes, 69% said evolution, 44% said creationism and 41% said ID. When given the option of three explanations of the origin of life, 48% of the 2,112 adults polled by Ipsos Mori between January 5 and 10 opted for evolution without God, 22% chose creationism and 17% chose ID. The Oxford University evolutionist Professor Richard Dawkins dismissed the results as "of very little interest". "If somebody professes disbelief in evolution, it is highly probable that they know nothing about it," he added. [At least he is not claiming that they are "insane" or "wicked" (see part #1)! But now it is Dawkins turn to delude himself! Note that he cannot bring himslef to say that "somebody doesn't believe in evolution," but rather "somebody professes disbelief in evolution"! Remember we are talking about "evolution" here in the context of the Ipsos MORI poll definition:

"1. The `evolution theory' says that human kind has developed over millions of years from less advanced forms of life. God had no part in this process." (my emphasis)

What about ID's Michael Behe, Bill Dembski and Jonathan Wells? Is Dawkins claiming that they "know nothing about it [evolution]"? Or what about lesser lights like yours truly who debated evolutionists on a daily basis for over a decade from 1994-2005, completed a biology degree in 2004, and yet still disbelieves "evolution"? The fact is that, due to decades of teaching of evolution in schools and universities, as well as in the media, it must be assumed that the public is not ignorant about evolution, yet a majority still do not accept it.]

"These ignorant people would probably welcome enlightenment. It is up to scientists to get out of their labs, from time to time, and enlighten." [This is a tacit admission of failure by Dawkins, who is the greatest living populariser of evolution, and Oxford University's Professor for the Public Understanding of Science. If Dawkins has not been able to "enlighten" an overwhelming majority of the public (in the land of Charles Darwin) to accept evolution, then how could the ordinary "scientists" in their "labs" do it? The problem for Dawkins and his ilk is that a large segment of the public is enlightened enough to decide that Dawkins' `blind watchmaker' ("God had no part in this process") version of evolution is inadequate. Indeed, I would not be surprised if those who rejected evolution know more about it than those who accepted it!]

The poll coincides with Horizon: A War on Science, which airs tonight on BBC2. ... [There is no "war on science." The general public has no problem with science generally. The "war" is against a "science" that has been taken hostage by an atheistic philosophy, whose very definition of their "science" is religious, i.e. what "God" (allegedly) did not do!]

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"

Friday, February 03, 2006

Britons unconvinced on evolution #1

News items about a poll in Britain (perhaps the first outside the USA?) which found that less than half (48%) accepted "evolution theory" and a total of 39% indicated either "creationism" (22%) or "intelligent design" (17%) as "their view of the origin and development of life." My comments are bold and in square brackets. Because of its size, I have split this into two parts.

Britons unconvinced on evolution, BBC, 26 January 2006 ... Just under half of Britons accept the theory of evolution as the best description for the development of life, according to an opinion poll. Furthermore, more than 40% of those questioned believe that creationism or intelligent design (ID) should be taught in school science lessons. [This Ipsos MORI poll adapted the three USA Gallup poll categories:

"1. The `evolution theory' says that human kind has developed over millions of years from less advanced forms of life. God had no part in this process. 2. The `creationism theory' says that God created human kind pretty much in his/her present form at one time within the last 10,000 years. 3. The `intelligent design theory' says that certain features of living things are best explained by the intervention of a supernatural being, e.g. God."

However, it has substituted the "intelligent design theory" for the Gallup poll's `God-guided evolution' category, "Human beings have developed over millions of years from less advanced forms of life, but God guided this process." So the 17% for ID is inflated. The high "don't know" (12%) presumably reflects this confusion (e.g. God-guided evolutionists who don't agree with ID).]

The survey was conducted by Ipsos MORI for the BBC's Horizon series. Its latest programme, A War on Science, looks into the attempt to introduce ID into science classes in the US. [There was no (and never has been any) "attempt to introduce ID into science classes in the US." The simple fact is that the only school board which ever got taken to court for allegedly attempting "to introduce ID into science classes in the US" is the Dover School District board, and all it did was require (against the policy of the ID movement) a 1-minute statement to be read before one science class each year, informing the students (what they probably all knew anyway) that: 1) there were problems with evolution; and 2) there was alternative ID material in the library!]

Over 2,000 participants took part in the survey, and were asked what best described their view of the origin and development of life: * 22% chose creationism * 17% opted for intelligent design * 48% selected evolution theory * and the rest did not know. [The 48% who selected "evolution theory" is about four times, and the 22% who chose "creationism" is about half the USA Gallup poll result. It should be no surprise that evolution is stronger and creationism weaker in the UK than the USA, it is a surprise that slightly more half the UK public reject "the standard scientific theory [of evolution] that `human beings have developed over millions of years from less advanced forms of life, but God had no part in this process.'" (Shermer M.B., "The Gradual Illumination of the Mind," Scientific American, February 2002. My emphasis)! So presumably Richard Dawkins (the Oxford Professor for the Public Understanding of Science) thinks that more than half his `constituents' are "ignorant, stupid or insane ... or wicked":

"It is absolutely safe to say that if you meet somebody who claims not to believe in evolution, that person is ignorant, stupid or insane (or wicked, but I'd rather not consider that)." (Dawkins R., "Put Your Money on Evolution," Review of Johanson D. & Edey M.A,, "Blueprints: Solving the Mystery of Evolution", in New York Times, April 9, 1989, sec. 7, p.34)

(Actually we will see in part 2 what Dawkins does think of it.) The UK science educators are worried that less school students are considering science as a career but is it any wonder when Dawkins has declared virtual war on half the British population.]

Intelligent design is the concept that certain features of living things are so complex that their existence is better explained by an "intelligent process" than natural selection. [This is one of the best definitions of ID that I have seen in the media. It suggests that it is slowly sinking in to the media's and the public's consciousness that, Darwinist disinformation notwithstanding, "ID ... is a secular scientific theory that intelligent causation is necessary to explain certain features of the natural world; and the evidence of that intelligent causation is empirically detectable."]... Andrew Cohen, editor of Horizon, commented: "I think that this poll represents our first introduction to the British public's views on this issue. "Most people would have expected the public to go for evolution theory, but it seems there are lots of people who appear to believe in an alternative theory for life's origins." [Ironically, Cohen's blurb for his Horizon program ends with the usual European looking down their noses at the USA on this issue:

"However, as history shows, law suits have little effect on the support for creationism in a country where over 50% of citizens believe that God created humans in their present form, the way the bible describes it"

when his own poll shows that he lives "in a country where 22% of citizens believe that God created humans in their present form!]

When given a choice of three descriptions for the development of life on Earth, people were asked which one or ones they would like to see taught in science lessons in British schools: * 44% said creationism should be included * 41% intelligent design * 69% wanted evolution as part of the science curriculum. [This is misleading. It was not 41% + 69% = 154%! There were in effect three questions to the same sample group, asked about 1. "Evolution theory"; 2. "Creationism theory" and 3. "Intelligent design theory," "whether ... they should or should not be taught in school science classes?" And in response to the question about whether "Evolution theory" should be taught, 69% of the same sample said it should be, with 15% against and 17% unsure. This is surprising that only slightly more that 2 out of 3 Britons are in favour of evolution being taught in science classes, given that it already is. Even more surprising is that to the questions whether "creation theory" and "intelligent design theory" should be taught in science classes, the responses were 44% and 41% in favour, respectively. This is less than the 64% of the USA public who want "creationism" (which may include "intelligent design") taught alongside evolution, but it is still surprisingly high.]

Participants over 55 were less likely to choose evolution over other groups. [It does not say how much "less likely," so it is unclear what significance this is. Anyway, the three questions were not asking the respondents to choose any one of the theories over the others.]

"This really says something about the role of science education in this country and begs us to question how we are teaching evolutionary theory," Andrew Cohen added. [Evolutionists always say this. They just cannot accept that the majority of the public have understood the main tenet of evolutionary theory, e.g. "human kind has developed over millions of years from less advanced forms of life. God had no part in this process" (my emphasis) and they have made a conscious, informed decision to reject it.

However, if there is something wrong with how evolutionary theory is taught, it is the evolutionists refusal to allow rival explanations (e.g. creation and ID) to be taught alongside evolution, so the students can hear the best evidence and arguments for each theory. But then the main problem would still remain, namely the evolutionists' insistence that "God had no part in this process," in a population where the majority are still theists. As David J. Young, an evolutionary biologist at Melbourne University pointed out in an Australian science journal, "if someone says `my science shows that your religion is bunk', the natural reaction is `well then there must be something wrong with your science'":

"There is an additional factor that needs to be taken into account here. The recent growth in the creationist movement has been matched by an increase in the number of popular science books on evolution, often written by authors who are openly hostile to religion. Some indeed have used their account of evolution to build an atheistic worldview at odds with any concept of creation or providence. Stephen Jay Gould, for example, has done this in his well-known books and essays (e.g. Wonderful Life, Dinosaur in a Haystack). He makes it clear that he believes humans are merely an accidental outcome of evolutionary history, the product of an uncaring Universe and not in any way created in God’s image. This view is not put forward as a personal opinion but is presented as a definite conclusion that science compels us to accept. It may seem like a small point but Gould, in the name of science, is dismissing a concept that is central to the Jewish and Christian religions. Small wonder, then, that the creationists rise up in protest. For the growth of the creationist movement has been fuelled by a sense of outrage at the way atheist beliefs and secular values are often presented as if they were part of biological science. To put it in the vernacular: if someone says `my science shows that your religion is bunk', the natural reaction is `well then there must be something wrong with your science.'" (Young D.J., "The Evolution of Creationism," Australasian Science, Vol. 23, No. 3, April 2002, pp.20-21)]

[Continued in part #2]

Stephen E. Jones, BSc (Biol).
"Problems of Evolution"